Luxury Places to Eat in Dorset: Five Favourite Restaurants We Return To Again and Again

A luxury holiday in Dorset isn’t just about where you stay. It’s also about discovering those special places where exceptional food, memorable settings and genuine hospitality meet. We’re often asked where we would choose to eat for a special occasion, a leisurely lunch with friends, or simply somewhere that feels a little different. A luxury place to eat and drink. While Dorset has no shortage of excellent restaurants and pubs, there are a handful of places we keep returning to time and again.

These aren’t listed because they’re fashionable or appear in guidebooks. They’re here because we’ve visited them ourselves and genuinely enjoy the experience they offer.

Whether you’re staying in one of our luxury holiday cottages in Dorset or simply planning a memorable meal during your visit, here are five of our favourites.

Shell Bay, Studland

If we were choosing a restaurant for a summer evening with friends, Shell Bay would be at the top of the list.

Set on the edge of Studland Bay, with beautiful views across the water towards Brownsea Island, it enjoys one of the most spectacular settings of any restaurant in Dorset. In fact, part of the experience begins before you’ve even sat down, as the stunning coastal scenery creates a sense of occasion from the moment you arrive.

We’ve dined here many times over the years and often bring visiting friends, who invariably comment on the setting. Our favourite time to visit is at sunset, when the light begins to soften across the bay and the views become even more memorable.

As you might expect from its location, seafood features prominently on the menu, but what we particularly like is that there is something for everyone. From beautifully prepared fish dishes to one of the best fish and chips you’ll find in Dorset, Shell Bay manages to feel relaxed while still delivering a genuinely special dining experience.

For us, it captures everything we love about luxury dining in Dorset: great food, exceptional views and an atmosphere that invites you to savour the moment.

Catch at Weymouth

There are restaurants that serve excellent food, and there are others that create an experience from start to finish.

For us, Catch in Weymouth clearly falls into the latter category.

We’ve enjoyed several meals here, and it remains one of our favourite restaurants for a special occasion. The moment you walk up the stairs, you sense that every detail has been carefully considered. The service is personal without being formal, and the attention to detail throughout the dining experience is impressive.

One of the things we particularly enjoy is the way each dish is presented. The team explain where the ingredients come from, how the fish was caught and how it has been prepared. This creates a stronger connection with both the food and Dorset’s incredible local produce.

The wine pairings are another highlight. The recommendations are always thoughtfully chosen and consistently complement each course.

For guests seeking a luxury dining experience in Weymouth, Catch is a place we recommend with complete confidence.

The Club House, West Bexington

There are few places in Dorset where you can enjoy lunch with a direct view across Chesil Beach, and that’s one of the reasons we love The Club House.

Set just moments from the shoreline in West Bexington, this is coastal dining at its best. Relaxed, stylish and perfectly positioned to make the most of one of Dorset’s most beautiful stretches of coastline.

One of our favourite experiences here is hiring one of the private beach huts on the garden terrace. If you’re celebrating a birthday, anniversary, or simply gathering friends, having your own dedicated space for the afternoon feels wonderfully indulgent.

The service is attentive without being intrusive, and the food is consistently excellent, with a strong focus on fresh seafood and locally sourced ingredients.

The combination of great food, sea air and uninterrupted coastal views creates a uniquely Dorset luxury experience that keeps us coming back year after year.

The Sailor’s Return, East Chaldon

Not every luxury dining experience requires white tablecloths and tasting menus.

Sometimes luxury is about atmosphere, authenticity and the feeling of being genuinely welcome. That’s exactly why The Sailor’s Return has become our favourite pub in Dorset.

Located in the tiny village of East Chaldon, just inland from the Jurassic Coast, this historic pub offers character, warmth and exceptional food in equal measure. The dining spaces are wonderfully rustic, creating a cosy atmosphere that feels especially inviting in the cooler months.

Owners Tom and Amelia are fantastic hosts who have created something genuinely special. The food is consistently excellent, and the quality of the ingredients shines through on the menu.

We’re clearly not the only people who think so. The Daily Telegraph included The Sailor’s Return in its list of the Top 500 Pubs in Britain, a recognition that is thoroughly deserved.

For guests seeking an authentic Dorset pub at its very best, this is always one of our first recommendations.

Salt, Portland Marina

Salt is one of those restaurants that feels special from the moment you arrive.

Located within Portland Marina, its waterside setting immediately creates a sense of occasion. Whether you’re dining inside or enjoying a table outdoors on a warm summer evening, there is something wonderfully relaxing about watching boats gently glide around the marina as you enjoy a meal. The interior is contemporary and well done, adding to the sense that you are dining somewhere special. 

We’ve become regular visitors because the overall experience is consistently impressive. The restaurant is beautifully designed, the service is polished and professional, and the food is complemented by a carefully selected wine list.

What we particularly enjoy is that Salt manages to balance sophistication with a welcoming atmosphere. It feels special without ever being intimidating.

On a sunny evening, few places in Dorset combine great food, excellent wine and a waterside setting quite so successfully. They also often have entertainment during the summer, which is great for an after-meal drink as the sun goes down.

Our Final Thoughts

One of the joys of staying in Dorset is that exceptional food can be found in all corners of the county, from coastal seafood restaurants overlooking the sea to historic village pubs tucked away in the countryside.

These five restaurants have become personal favourites because each offers something slightly different, yet they all share the qualities we value most: great food, genuine hospitality and memorable surroundings.

If you’re planning a luxury escape to Dorset, we’d encourage you to book in advance and experience one or two during your stay.

And if you’re still searching for the perfect place to stay, explore our collection of luxury holiday cottages in Dorset, carefully selected to complement the very best experiences the county offers.

Looking For Something Even More Special?

While Dorset’s restaurants offer wonderful dining experiences, the most memorable meals sometimes happen without leaving your holiday cottage.

For guests celebrating a birthday, anniversary, family gathering or special occasion, our concierge service can help create something truly unique. From arranging a private chef to cook and serve dinner in your cottage to organising locally sourced hampers and wine deliveries for your arrival, we can help make your stay even more memorable.

For those seeking a truly memorable evening, we can also arrange unique dining experiences, including private dining in a historic courtroom or the chance to cook alongside a Michelin-trained chef. These carefully curated experiences offer something a little different and are perfect for celebrations, family gatherings and luxury Dorset escapes.

Many of these experiences can be enjoyed from the comfort of one of our luxury holiday cottages in Dorset, allowing you to combine exceptional accommodation with unforgettable dining and drinking experiences.

Explore our Concierge Services, discover our Curated Experiences, or browse our collection of Luxury Holiday Cottages in Dorset to plan your perfect stay

Frequently Asked Questions